Swiss central bank President Philipp Hildebrand, who ended 15 months of intervening in foreign- exchange markets this year, may prove powerless to stop the franc from extending a record rally that he calls a “burden.”
Options traders are more bullish on the franc for the next three months than any major currency except the yen, according to data compiled by Bloomberg. Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ Ltd. says it may appreciate 7.9 percent to 1.17 per euro in six months after rising more than any major peer since intervention ended in June. Standard Bank Plc estimates an advance to 1.20.
Currency traders say Hildebrand probably won’t renew efforts to stop the gains after previous sales failed to halt the appreciation that made exports more expensive and saddled the Swiss National Bank with $22 billion of exchange-rate losses in the first nine months of 2010. While policy makers said on June 21 that intervention was no longer needed as the risk of deflation had ebbed, price increases have since slowed.
“The SNB cannot do much, they are just observers,” said Beat Siegenthaler, a Zurich-based currency strategist at UBS AG, ranked by Euromoney Institutional Investor Plc as the world’s second-biggest foreign-exchange trader. “Of course they are very worried. Their options are limited.”
The franc advanced 1.2 percent last week to 1.2627 per euro, climbing to a record 1.2439 on Dec. 22. It gained 0.7 percent against the dollar to 96.23 centimes, extending its 2010 rise to 7.6 percent. The Swiss currency rose 0.1 percent against the euro and dollar as of 12:51 p.m. in Tokyo today.
Monetary Union
Switzerland’s currency, a haven in times of economic turmoil, has strengthened 17 percent against the euro this year amid concern the fiscal crisis engulfing Greece, Ireland, Portugal and Spain will curb growth in the 16-country region and may force some nations out of the monetary union.
The franc’s gain against the euro is an additional “burden” for Swiss exports, which account for about 50 percent of gross domestic product, Hildebrand, 47, told reporters in Zurich on Dec. 16. Growth in Switzerland’s $492 billion economy is likely to be “significantly lower in the quarters ahead,” partly because of the currency’s strength, he said.
Werner Abegg, a spokesman for the central bank, declined a Bloomberg News request to arrange interviews with policy makers.
The SNB said it had started selling on March 12, 2009, its first solo foreign-exchange intervention since 1992. The policy, designed to ward off deflation, protect exports and revive growth, sparked the biggest one-day decline since the euro’s 1999 start. The franc slumped 3.4 percent to 1.5299 per euro. By the end of June 2010, it had strengthened 16 percent to 1.3184.
SNB’s Losses
The central bank said on Nov. 12 that it had a nine-month loss of 8.46 billion francs ($8.8 billion) after depreciation in the euro and dollar caused its holdings to decline in value by 21.2 billion francs. A year earlier, the 103-year-old bank reported a profit of 6.89 billion francs.
“The SNB tried intervening, and that clearly didn’t work, so they stepped away,” said Richard Benson, a London-based executive director at Millennium Asset Management, who oversees $14 billion of currency funds. The franc “will carry on strengthening whilst the stresses and strains of the euro zone cease to be resolved,” he said.
Derivative traders are paying a 2.56 percentage-point premium for three-month call options, which grant the right to buy the franc against the euro, relative to puts, which allow for sales, Bloomberg data show. That compares with an average premium of about 1 percentage point over the past two years.
Ratings Downgrades
The franc may strengthen toward 1.10 per euro next year as the debt crisis in Europe intensifies, Lee Hardman, a London- based strategist at Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi, wrote in a note to clients on Dec. 22.
Fitch Ratings cut Portugal’s debt rating one level to A+ on Dec. 23, citing concern about the “financing environment” for the government. Moody’s Investors Service said on Dec. 15 it may reduce Spain’s Aa1 credit rating and a day later placed Greece’s Ba1 classification on review for a possible downgrade direct payday lenders. Ireland was cut five levels by Moody’s on Dec. 17. Switzerland has top AAA rating from the three companies.
Analyst forecasts remain bearish on gains by the franc. As recently as Nov. 30, the median of 28 estimates compiled by Bloomberg was for the franc to end 2010 at 1.33 per euro. The currency will trade at 1.30 by the end of March, a separate survey of 34 strategists showed.
Some investors say the franc is too strong, with the nation’s benchmark interest rate 0.75 percentage point below the European Central Bank’s 1 percent. Two-year notes yielded 48 basis points less than German securities of similar maturity on Dec. 23, compared with 39 basis points at the end of September.
Relative Value
The currency is 34 percent overvalued against the euro, based on the relative costs of tradable goods and services as measured by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development in Paris.
“The market is getting a little carried away with its concern over the European sovereign-debt risks,” said Jurgen Buscher, Zurich-based head of JB Private Asset Management and the former director of foreign exchange at Deutsche Bank Private Wealth Management. The franc may weaken to the 1.30 per euro to 1.40 over the next year, he said.
Switzerland’s trade surplus, which frees the country from dependence on foreign capital and can prompt purchases during times of turmoil, declined to 1.93 billion francs last month from 2.05 billion francs in October, the Federal Customs Office said on Dec. 21.
While the stronger franc helped spur a 3.4 percent drop in exports last month, the Swiss economy is benefiting from its proximity to Germany, according to Steven Barrow, head of Group of 10 currency strategy at Standard Bank in London.
‘Saving Grace’
German gross domestic product will grow 3.6 percent this year, more than double the 1.7 percent for the euro region, according to economists’ estimates compiled by Bloomberg. Switzerland’s GDP will rise 2.7 percent, the forecasts show.
The currency gain “is obviously detrimental as far as trade is concerned,” Barrow said. “The saving grace has been that Switzerland’s closest trading neighbors, northern Europe and Germany in particular, have actually been quite strong.”
Germany’s benchmark DAX Index of stocks has rallied 18 percent this year, while the Swiss Market Index is little changed from the end of 2009.
Swiss economic growth will probably slow by a percentage point next year to 1.7 percent, according to the median in a Bloomberg survey of 13 economists. That compares with 1.45 percent for the euro area and 2.5 percent in Germany, surveys show. Greece and Portugal will likely contract, with Spain’s GDP increasing by 0.6 percent.
Inflation Forecast
Hildebrand cut the central bank’s 2012 inflation forecast to 1 percent on Dec. 16 from 1.2 percent, almost six months after SNB Vice Chairman Thomas Jordan said that intervention was no longer necessary because the threat of deflation had largely disappeared. Consumer prices increased 0.2 percent in November from a year earlier, down from a 1.1 percent gain in May.
Policy makers said in their quarterly report on Dec. 24 that “if a deflation risk emerges, the SNB would take the measures necessary to ensure price stability,” repeating a statement made from their meeting a week earlier.
They may still have to live with a stronger currency as long as the euro area remains in crisis, according to Collin Crownover, head of currency management at State Street Global Advisors Inc. in Boston, which manages $1.9 trillion of assets.
“The issues in the euro-zone periphery won’t be solved, they will continue into next year,” said Crownover. “I don’t see the SNB coming back in again. Of course there is always a set of circumstances where they feel they have to. But in absence of really strong appreciation, they are most likely going to be on the sidelines. They got very little for their intervention.”
Source